The announcement set forth a wave of discussions. A significant chunk of the Meta users has expressed dissatisfaction and asked the question of why the company has decided to promote yet another feed plastered with AI-generated videos when other social platforms are already overwhelmed by the issue of a plethora of AI-generated videos. Although lower in quality, they are still generated in bulk. This paper attempts to dive deeper into the user-generated video feed suggestion, user response to the feature, Meta’s AI strategy, and the potential risks.
What Are Vibes?
| Vibes is an attempt by Meta to position the company as a leader in the creation and sharing of AI-generated content. Users can do the following: |
| Create an original video using the text-to-video prompt function |
| Remix videos they wish to from the global pop list. |
| Users may enhance their videos with visuals, audio, and other elements before they publish their work. |
| Users may utilize the Vibes feed as well as direct messaging, Instagram stories, and Facebook reels to share their content. |
| As Meta develops its own AI capabilities, Black Forest Labs and Midjourney have been given the task of work on the first iterations of Vibes. |
| With time, the algorithm will begin to recommend personalized AI videos, akin to the “For You” section of TikTok. |
Among the content samples discussed by Zuckerberg were fuzzy, colorful creatures leapfrogging across blocks, a fluffy cat furiously kneading dough, and a still of a woman, presumably Egyptian, snapping a selfie amidst some ancient ruins. They are fun, odd, and artistic, but also suffer from the “AI slop” issue that many critics are articulating.
User Reaction: Confused and Angered
The response to Vibes so far has not been a glowing one. Many critics and casual observers alike were baffled by Zuckerberg’s Instagram post, with some users saying “Nobody wants this” and others derisively stating that we do not need AI on every platform.
This backlash is a microcosm of the criticisms that can be directed towards existing social media. Users are probably aware that the feeds of Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok are heavily populated with the same videos and posts, and that the growth of AI has enabled users to post videos and content that, while interesting to look at, are stale in terms of human creativity and input.
The balance of many users suggests that Meta is out of sync with what social media is supposed to be: a platform for genuine interaction and creative storytelling.
Meta told creators to focus on originality and warned against ‘unoriginal’ content a few months ago. Vibes seems to contradict this message.
Why is Meta Pushing AI Videos?
Despite the backlash, there are justifications for Meta’s decision to use Vibes. The company is investing in AI to keep pace with competitors like OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google DeepMind.
In June, Meta reorganized to form new teams and created a division called ‘Meta Superintelligence Labs’ to spearhead its AI strategy. This division was the focus of 4 teams that concentrated on foundation models, AI research, product integration and infrastructure.
With Vibes, Meta intends to make AI a part of its consumer-facing products and not just a behind-the-scenes feature. This also allows Meta to observe real-time interactions with AI-generated videos, which in turn grants the company valuable information.
Another driving factor is competition. TikTok and YouTube reign supreme in the short videos sphere. Meta may offer something novel that stands out from the rest of its apps by incorporating AI. Even if the feature is not widely embraced, Meta may anticipate that younger audiences will adopt AI video as a new form of creativity.
The Problem of AI Slop
The risk that Meta has taken with the Vibes feature has to do with the backlash that so-called ‘AI Slop’ has generated. Slop describes AI imagery, video, or text that, while visually impressive, evokes a sense of emptiness.
| AI Slop can come in the following forms: |
| Weird or nonsensical imagery that fails to amuse and actively confounds. |
| An overabundance of material that surpasses human output. |
| Absent authenticity, many AI works plagiarize learned schemas and patterns in training data. |
YouTube and similar platforms have started to implement measures that reduce the spread of ‘AI Slop.’ Audiences have grown more sophisticated in their differentiation of the compound and the created. The addition of Vibes could further alienate the user base Meta already has, as they have become over-saturated with ‘low-quality’ content.
A Strategic Gamble
The Vibes feature could singlehandedly position Meta as one of the leaders in AI-focused entertainment. From a business standpoint, Meta has the dual prospect of being Vibes’ initiator alongside becoming its likely victim. Users could find value in the AI video feature as a tool for creativity and fun, which could offer seamless integration for user engagement within Meta platforms.
On the contrary, the AI video feature could turn into a source of embarrassment for Meta if users perceive it as spam or refuse to engage with it.
User comments suggest skepticism. Meta has a history of features that never took off. Copying Snapchat with Facebook Stories or pushing the metaverse with Horizon Worlds has not become mainstream.
The risk is not just about user reaction. It also pertains to the identity of Meta. The company often espouses the value of authentic connection, community, and creativity. An AI-slop-dominated feed does not reinforce that value, and trust is weakened.
The Larger AI Race
Meta has continuously and publicly experienced the need to keep pace with OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Anthropic’s Claude, and Google DeepMind’s models.
Meta has positioned itself within the situation and introduced partnerships with Midjourney and Black Forest Labs, which suggests its awareness that it cannot solely depend on its own models. Meta has released large language models, such as Llama, and also integrated AI systems within WhatsApp, Messenger, and Instagram, but the public still regards Meta as a laggard. The introduction of the flashy AI video feed may also signal a desire to dominate the headlines and showcase Meta’s momentum.
The company is collaborating with specialists to deploy new features while simultaneously building internal capabilities quickly.
Will Vibes Work?
The primary concern is whether Vibes will be a successful venture or a failed one. This concern mainly deals with three factors.
| User adoption: A feature’s growth is guaranteed if a significant number of users engage with and find value in the feature, even if the initial reception is a lukewarm one. |
| Content quality: Videos that are boring, duplicate, or meaningless are a downgrade to Vibes, and if the platform is overrun with such content, users will abandon the platform. Meta has to make sure that the tools designed encourage users to think outside the box and be original. |
| Integration with Meta apps: Vibes, unlike the previous tools, connects with Instagram and Facebook. Its success in these platforms would rely on users’ willingness to cross-post Vibes-generated AI content into their existing feeds. |
The forecast is rather gloomy. There is a lack of demand for AI-generated videos, and skepticism from users is at an all-time high. Regardless, Meta has the means and the time to keep on innovating until a profitable venture is created.
Assumption
The launch of Vibes from Meta serves as an equal parts reminder of the risks and the rewards of implementing artificial intelligence into social media tools. On the one hand, it is a bold move into a new sector of creative AI and an indication that Meta has no intentions to fall behind in the AI race.
Conversely, there are concerns that the feature could inundate social media platforms with content considered low-value “AI slop” by countless users.
At a period in which users are already exasperated with so much regurgitated content online, this will not be the first time that the company will have to demonstrate how Vibes goes beyond gimmickry to genuine utility. Whether this gamble pays off depends on user behavior in the months to come. For now, the launch reflects a company that remains most willing to pivot to AI technology, but is still unsure of the appetite the public has for the feature.
Discover more from Being Shivam
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.