In a market that is sensitive to retail performance and consumer spending, Amazon’s success during October’s deal days could influence sentiment heading into the holiday season.
What Happened During Prime Big Deal Days
Amazon’s Prime Big Deal Days ran over 48 hours, from October 7 to October 8, offering time-limited discounts across multiple categories exclusively for Prime members. The event is positioned as a fall counterpart to its summer Prime Day and serves as a kickoff to holiday shopping.
To draw users in, Amazon introduced new deals periodically, sometimes every few minutes, and refreshed its “Today’s Big Deals” promotions. The promotions spanned tech, home goods, fashion, beauty, and kitchen appliances. In its own reporting, Amazon highlighted major discounts from brands like Apple, Dyson, and Lego across more than 35 product categories.
Consumer feedback was largely positive. According to survey data from Numerator, 58% of participants rated their deal satisfaction as “very” or “extremely” satisfied. About 35% of shoppers said the sale was their main reason for shopping during those days, and 23% used the event to buy holiday gifts ahead of time.
However, amid the hype some scrutiny emerged. A Washington Post analysis suggested that average savings across tracked items were negligible (only 0.6%) and some “discounted” listings matched previous prices.
That report warned that Amazon’s use of inflated reference prices may create misleading impressions of value. The tension between promotional appeal and perceived authenticity thus forms part of the narrative around these kinds of sales.
In terms of seller dynamics, offers from Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) were seen to perform better than merchant-fulfilled listings, reflecting consumer preference for Prime-eligible delivery. (Third-party commentary observed this trend during the event.)
Overall, the mechanics of the event, fresh deal drops, and broad category reach contributed to Amazon’s narrative of executing a successful promotional campaign that attracted both deal hunters and holiday shoppers.
Analyst Response & Market Reaction
Analysts reacted positively following Amazon’s Prime Big Deal Days. Telsey Advisory Group reaffirmed its Outperform rating and held firm on a $265 price target. According to Investing, Telsey stated that Amazon executed well across marketing, product mix, pricing, and operations, thereby strengthening its positioning heading into the holiday season.
Other firms echoed that view. BMO Capital also reiterated an Outperform rating, noting that the Big Deal Days launch was well received and pointing to continued strength in Amazon’s core businesses such as its cloud and retail segments.
In financial markets, Amazon’s stock saw upward momentum in the wake of the event. Investors appeared to interpret strong execution during Big Deal Days as evidence of resilience in consumer demand, even under macro pressures. That optimism is tempered by caution from others who raise questions about discount quality and margin compression.
Some critics have drawn attention to pricing analyses suggesting that actual savings during Big Deal Days were minimal. A Washington Post investigation found that among roughly 50 sampled products, many were priced higher than in prior months, leading to a net “savings” of only 0.6% in that sample.
Those findings fuel skepticism among value-conscious investors who worry that Amazon may be using inflated reference prices to make discounts appear more attractive.
Overall, the market reaction reflects a balance: confidence that Amazon can deliver during key retail moments, while also acknowledging risk around promotional authenticity and margin pressure.
How This Event Fits Into Amazon’s Strategy
Prime Big Deal Days plays a deliberate role in Amazon’s retail calendar. It serves as a fall anchor event to jumpstart holiday shopping, bridging the gap between summer’s Prime Day and the major year-end retail push.
Amazon appears to use such events to combine retail and advertising growth levers. Deep discounts and time-limited offers attract volume, while higher visibility and bidding in Amazon’s ad platform help push product discovery and monetization.
In effect, the sales event gives Amazon more control over the narrative of promotions and foot traffic. In a Forbes article, brands are advised to carefully coordinate pricing and visibility during these events to “take advantage” of Amazon’s scale.
For sellers, the mechanics of Big Deal Days favor those using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA). Faster delivery, better visibility, and Prime-eligibility often translate into better conversion compared to merchant-fulfilled (FBM) listings.
An analysis by Amplifyy highlights how sellers who prepared their inventory, paced their ad spending, and staggered promotions saw stronger performance.
Over time, these periodic deal events help Amazon capture early holiday demand, lock in loyal spending, and shape customer expectations of what a “deal” looks like on its platform.
However, Amazon must manage tradeoffs: steep discounts can erode margins, and overuse of promotional events can lead to deal fatigue or consumer skepticism.
Conclusion
Going forward, several areas will be critical to monitor. First, whether momentum from Big Deal Days carries into Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and year-end. The ability to sustain sales lift will test whether this event was a one-off boost or part of a larger uptrend.
Second, Amazon’s operating margins will be under scrutiny. Deep discounts and promotional costs may weigh on profitability. The question is whether Amazon can maintain discipline while driving volume.
Third, performance in AWS and its advertising business will shape investor confidence. Strong growth in these higher-margin segments could offset retail margin pressure.
Fourth, pricing scrutiny will persist. If independent analyses continue to find weak actual savings, it could undercut the credibility of Amazon’s promotional claims.
Finally, consumer sentiment and competitive responses will matter. If shoppers perceive deals as superficial, or competing retailers undercut aggressively, Amazon may face headwinds.
In sum, Prime Big Deal Days added momentum and reinforced positive sentiment. Yet the true test will come in execution over the rest of the year.
Discover more from Being Shivam
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.